I'm Todd Sieling, and I've been designing information architecture, software experiences and product management for over twelve years. I help product managers, marketing agencies & dev teams develop web and iOS products that are humane and business-smart.

Learn how I help make better software experiences

The Four-Legged Dance

Apr 27th, 2009 No comments yet. Tags: , , ,

Last week Garrett Murray’s commentary on the state reviewing culture on the iTunes App Store reviews circulated through the the blogaverse, catching my eye by way of Lachlan’s Pool Room.

Garrett’s application, Ego (iTunes Link), lets iPhone users check in on their Google Analytics stats on the go. A snafu with Analytics caused his app to be blocked, but in true web spirit Google and Garrett worked out the problem, and an update to Ego was submitted into the App Store’s approval process, which takes about a week.

Meanwhile, on the App Store and Get Satisfaction, Ego customers reacted badly, giving rise to the Garrett’s two core grievances on how commenting on the App Store and elsewhere works:

  • Reviewers can be quick to criticize and don’t read every detail before doing so.
  • The App Store doesn’t give developers a way to respond to specific comments, or comments in general.

These are fair criticisms, one rooted in problematic human-computer expectations (and if we acronymize that to HCE, we can go on speaking tour), and the other in the design of the interface at the App Store. Along with people commenting on Ego’s problem, we have Google Analytics and the App Store not coming off very well. But there’s a fourth leg in this interaction dance, which is how the Ego app itself handled the unexpected use case of being blocked by Google. Read more »

Fresh (Word)Press

Apr 9th, 2009 No comments yet. Tags: , ,

It must be spring, because I’ve once again dug up and re-built the setup for this site.

This year,it’s a move back to Retrix for hosting, a change of engine to WordPress from Typo. So far I’m finding this new ride to be exceptionally comfortable, and owe a big thanks to the WordPress and its community for what they’ve built. Typo is a nice system, with one of the nicer admin interfaces, to boot, but we just weren’t right for each other. C’est la vie.

The move was relatively easy, heavy lifting done by Adam Roth for migration and Tzaddi Gordon for custom theming. A mobile theme is available thanks to Brave New Code’s WPtouch iPhone Plugin. It packs a lot of theming control into one plugin, and is well worth a donation given how simple to use and effective it is in generating an almost instant yet complete mobile theme. Bam!

So, a few rough edges remain in migrating content, and my plugin curiosity isn’t sated quite yet. Please pardon any messiness around here for the next few days.

SxSW Interactive Journal: 2009

ia_icon.gif Spring is in the air, and to celebrate I joined in the annual pilgrimage to Austin for the South by Southwest Interactive conference. This is my second year attending, and though knowing the lay of land makes many things easier, every day still has more than one can possibly take in. The days full of sessions, packed with more food for thought than a week’s reading in regular times. The nights are filled with events, many offering free drinks. Since it’s rude to refuse a drink, one must take pains to visit them all and not risk offending the hosts. In between, it’s a carnival of BBQ, which isn’t so great if you’re vegetarian, but makes for good memories for the omnivorous.

Normally on trips like this my SLR camera would be a nearly-constant companion, making the best of a fresh context and different light. I got in some decent still shots, but most of my recreational photography was with a Flip Mino HD camcorder. I had this in my pocket most of the time, and shot about an hour’s worth of footage. A few hours in iMovie 09 has trimmed that down to about 8 minutes.

Read more »

Election Apps Choke on Election Day

Nov 4th, 2008 No comments yet. Tags: , ,

One more for the election. A few weeks ago I wrote about the nifty iPhone app from the Obama campaign, which I still think is a beautiful piece of work and the start of a new era in campaign organization.

At the time I thought that for certain the app would make a big deal about getting out to vote on election day. But when I fired it up to check this morning, I was let down.

obamaapp-electionday.jpg

What kinds of features should an election day mode take on? Time left before polling stations close, a map to your registered polling station, where to call and what to do if you’re turned away or witness irregularities, and of course, a way to document your voting experience and share it online. That’s all for version 2, I guess, but smart money is working on a white-label approach to this kind of application for the next elections, that’s for sure.

Another app that I’d been loving but didn’t come through today was the Slate poll tracker.

slateapp.jpg

The Slate app is a small masterpiece in poll tracking, offering both just enough info for a quick stop, or in depth as far as you want to go within the window of recently relevant results. This app kept me entertained through more than one lunch, I’m embarrassed to say. If I could have wished for one thing it would have been results tracking mode. Again, the ball is dropped on designing for the big day.

The really big winner for today’s election in the United States? Well, that one is obvious, and it’s welcome news indeed.

Obama App: Is this the Future of Electoral Campaigns?

Oct 3rd, 2008 No comments yet. Tags: , ,

obama-home.jpg

Yesterday saw the launch of an iPhone application for the Obama campaign. Big deal? Yes, I do think it is.

While electoral campaigns have been getting hip to mobile technology for a few years now, all that I’ve known of only treat the devices only as outbound communication targets, with the person holding the handset as the end-point in the experience. That view focussed on the output, such as a news update, as the end in itself and ignored the user’s desired outcome: becoming a more effective advocate for one’s chosen candidate. Appropriately, while listening to both the Canadian and US leadership debates last night, I spent some time with the Obama app and found the start of a whole new game for how campaigns look at smartphones, and possibly for how future elections will be fought and won.

The Obama app could have been so much less, a mere aggregator and a pretty face for a bunch of newsfeeds and media sources. Instead, the experience prefers the user’s ability to reach outward and to make action happen on the spot more than it treats them as audience.

Campaign communication traditionally rests on what I call the hopeful interruption model: the phone call as you come out of the shower, the appeal to register while you’re on your way to lunch, the leaflet that arrives with bills. They all try to make the best of an unexpected interruption, and at best it’s a hit and miss operation.

The Obama app leaves hopeful interruption behind and becomes part of a primary mobile communication, productivity and entertainment device. As the one thing someone is likely to have with them out on the street, it opens the most critical campaign channels to on-the-spot interactions. In other words, it situates a campaign’s resources comfortably in the social reality of an electoral race.

Highlight Parade

Ring-Ring, ObamaPhone

The application integrates with the phone and contact list, and offers for using the phone aspect of the application and a note on privacy. A is built in, and by state.

By tapping into the existing address book and putting its own sorting into action, the application instantly becomes a one-person call center, noting who hasn’t yet been called and letting users show off some basic stats for time and effort spent.

Newsitainment

The Obama app contains its own as well as a news aggregator, which isn’t very new in itself but within this context is a no-brainer.

Talking Points

A pocket encyclopedia of Obama’s position on various issues offers summary points for answering questions and getting talking points on the spot. The amount of information to be found in this section alone likely equals about 3 kilos of campaign literature leaflets in the pocket, all the time. It needs a search, but it’s a great start. I can see this part being used openly or quietly amid discussions over the issues.

Come Together

Two very important features for getting people involved in-person leverage location-awareness: finding local events and local offices where one can get more involved. I couldn’t get far with these features, being in Vancouver, Canada where Obama is surely not campaigning, but their utility is clear: make it easy to find and join into the real-world gatherings that truly energize voters.

Update Opt-In

Here’s the real make or break point in finding a new way of thinking about electoral communication: Receive Updates. Rather than assume that because the application has been installed, the user is now open to a firehose of updates, the Obama app asks you to . No new channel for team Obama to manage, and an extra bit of consideration for the user’s attention. That care for permission and the value of attention, though technically simple, is a moment of brilliance in campaign communication thinking.

Make a Difference Right Now

For the nuts and bolts of a campaign, there are two things that matter most: the money and the vote. The home screen brings these two together near the bottom, marked by an eye-catching green button to kick off a new donation. When a mind changes, when a sensibility is outraged and demands change, it’s a prime time for capturing a donation. Tapping the button , requiring no transaction through the iPhone itself, but instead tapping into the built, operating and proven channel for taking donations that is already there.

Also near the bottom is a countdown of days to the election, and I’ll be sure to check on the app on election day to see what it does then. The application does nothing that is particular to only the iPhone, so I think it can be ported with ease to other smartphone platforms. And to other campaigns.

What makes the Obama app a game-changer for campaigns in general is its potential to turn any interested supporter into a supported and connected campaigner in 5 minutes, and for turning interest into action at many points through the contest. Elections are probably the most complicated and drawn out conversion processes, aiming to capture the ultimate clickthrough: someone’s vote. The ingenuity and imagination of the Obama app for iPhone raises the bar to something new. Watch for it in, oh, about three and a half years.

How Not to Buy an iPhone

Jul 18th, 2008 Comments 5 Tags: ,

I’ve played it pretty low key as the iPhone has debuted in Canada, and while doing so has kept me out of long lineups, it’s been a haystack of frustration and misdirection from Fido. The Rogers subsidiary took my order by phone on July 11 around 3pm, and promised a delivery on July 18. My number would be transferred, my voice plan changed and the data plan magically activated that day. Call back for a tracking number, the agent cheerfully encouraged.

So I did, on Tuesday. The phone hadn’t shipped, and now it likely wouldn’t be in my hands until August 1. Why? No explanation.

Call #2, Wednesday. No, it’s not shipped, and now almost certainly won’t be in my hands until Aug 1. Why? The information was incorrect. We chatted a bit about whether I was misled or whether Fido is simply incompetent, at which point the customer service agent became angry, raised his voice with me and kept cutting my sentences short. I calmed the agent down, and asked to speak to a supervisor. After agreeing to that and checking for ‘availability’, he returned and said a supervisor would call back. Then he changed his mind and said there would be no supervisor callback until after the 18th, to ‘see if it comes anyway’. Without a tracking number. Right.

Call #3, Today. I asked if I could just go to a store and see if they had any in stock, as I’ve been hearing and reading that some stores do. It’s impossible to do that, I’ve been told. Today’s reason is that it’s all UPSs fault, that they can’t deliver them fast enough and that’s why it will be two weeks late. Why not – it was fiction on July 11, it might as well be fiction today.

When I asked about the activation of the data plan on the 18th even though I don’t have the phone, I was told that would go ahead. So I was expected to just pay for half a month of service I can’t use. Very nice. Oh, and here’s a further catch: the data plan doesn’t activate until midnight of the day you ask for the plan. So if you buy an iPhone at 8am, you pay .05/kb until midnight that evening. Sweet ride.

I convinced today’s agent to take the data plan off, but it’s my responsibility to call back and put it back on if and when I receive a phone. I mentioned that I might go and buy from Rogers, and was told I can’t cancel the order. I promised a chargeback on my visa and a report to Better Business Bureau if that happened, and demanded the first and last name of the agent. She challenged me to cancel my account then and there, cutting off phone service altogether.

I’m still considering what to do. Switch to Rogers? Stay with Fido and their mouthy phone agents, so brave and bold when protected by the distance of a phone line? I haven’t done much looking around to see if there are actually iPhones in Rogers stores in town, and I don’t like spending that much time chasing a device, but I feel like I’m getting the runaround from Fido, and that they don’t want my business.

I guess we’ll see about that ‘supervisor callback within 5 business days’. By then I might not even be a customer, which tells you a lot about Fido under Rogers:

  • They change their story every call.
  • They’re rude.
  • They blame partner companies for their own problems, which they started by promising a date.
  • Worst of all, they take zero responsibility for their mis-steps. I can forgive a lot, but not that.

And it’s not really worth writing more at this point. I only know of one other industry that treats people so badly while demanding thousands of dollars for service, and that’s air travel. I fly very little these days, mostly because I think air travel is done so poorly it’s not worth it. Trying to buy an iPhone from Fido has been just as fun, and might not even be worth it.

Update:
Fido becomes responsive when talk of account cancellation and chargebacks come into play. Late yesterday, a Fido supervisor accelerated my order and ensured its delivery, along with activation of all the right services, and today I received an iPhone ready to rock after a short transfer call. That’s great news, but it came after so much aggravation and misdirection that it feels more like finishing a forced march across the dessert.

Today I missed the callback from the Fido supervisor, whom I hope to thank for the attention, and to let him know where things went wrong. I’d call him back, but the number comes through as Unknown Number. From a telecom provider. Poetic, really.

Mr. iPhone Comes to Canada and Causes a Stir

Jul 10th, 2008 No comments yet. Tags: , ,

canphone.jpg If you’ve heard much about the iPhone lately, you’ve heard about the fracas over the rates announced by Rogers and its subsidiary Fido, the 3G model’s exclusive Canadian carriers.

iPhone Fever, Canadian Style

Read more »